If you've ever stood in front of the Cooking Pot in Grow a Garden wondering “What's the best recipe for Chris P.?”, you're in the right place.
I've spent hours experimenting, burning a few meals (sorry, Chris P.), and figuring out exactly what rewards you can get—and more importantly, how to get the good stuff.

Here's the full reward list, sorted by tier, plus practical steps so you can start cooking your way to rare seeds, pets, and cosmetics.
Step 1 – Gather Your Crops
Head to your garden and pick what's ready. Rare seeds give you better odds at high-tier meals.
Step 2 – Use the Cooking Pot
The Cooking Pot lets you combine different crops into one meal. Try mixing rarities—basic crops alone usually lead to Common rewards.
Step 3 – Serve the Meal to Chris P.
Chris P. will taste your creation. If he likes it, he'll hand over rewards from a tier that matches your recipe's quality.
Step 4 – Aim for Higher Tiers
The better the recipe, the rarer the loot. Legendary or higher is where the real treasures are.
| Reward | Tier |
|---|---|
| 1T Sheckles | Common |
| x1 Mutation Spray Burnt | Common |
| x1 Fork Fence | Common |
| x5 Watering Cans | Common |
| x1 Food Crate | Uncommon |
| x1 Reclaimer | Uncommon |
| x3 Corn Seeds | Uncommon |
| x1 Gourmet Seed Pack | Rare |
| x1 Artichoke Seed | Rare |
| x1 Advanced Sprinkler | Rare |
| x2 Small Toys | Legendary |
| x1 Gourmet Egg | Legendary |
| x2 Mutation Spray HoneyGlazed | Legendary |
| x1 Pretzel Cart | Mythical |
| x2 Gourmet Seed Packs | Mythical |
| x1 Medium Toy | Mythical |
| x1 Mochi Mouse | Divine |
| x2 Food Crates | Divine |
| x1 Pet Mutation Shard Fried | Divine |
| x3 Mutation Spray Fried | Divine |
| x1 Pancake Stack Cosmetic | Prismatic |
| x1 Taco Fern Seed | Prismatic |
| x3 Gourmet Eggs | Prismatic |
| x4 Gourmet Seed Packs | Prismatic |
Here's what I've learned after dozens of cooking sessions:
If you keep experimenting and recording your best results, you’ll steadily climb into the higher reward tiers. Before long, you’ll be swimming in rare seeds, special gear, and maybe even some unique pets to show off. And if you’re looking to expand your collection even further, don’t forget to check out the grow a garden pet shop—it’s the perfect place to find companions that make your garden feel truly alive.
(Tested as of the latest patch—works for me, but RNG still applies)
Cooking in Grow a Garden isn't just about filling Chris P.'s belly—it's one of the fastest ways to score rare seeds, special pets, and exclusive cosmetics.
If you focus on crop variety and keep notes on what works, you'll be seeing Prismatic-tier rewards like the Pancake Stack Cosmetic in no time.