A hit into the gap can create two different decisions: whether the lead runner should score and where the batter should stop. Using one command for both can waste a scoring opportunity. Before spending Stubs on faster players, learn to select runners individually so you can send one home while holding another at second.
MLB The Show 26 offers Analog and Buttons baserunning control schemes. Their individual-runner inputs differ, so check your selected scheme before practicing.
| Control Scheme | Individual-Runner Selection |
|---|---|
| Analog | Point the left stick toward the runner, then press the button for the desired base. |
| Buttons | Hold the button corresponding to the runner’s current base, then press a directional button to choose the destination. |
Analog uses the left stick to select the runner and a face button to choose the destination. Buttons uses a face button to select the runner and a directional input to choose the destination.
Use the following base-button reference with your selected control scheme.
| Base | PlayStation | Xbox | Nintendo Switch |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | Circle | B | A |
| Second | Triangle | Y | X |
| Third | Square | X | Y |
| Home / batter | Cross | A | B |
In Analog, these face buttons identify the destination. In Buttons, they identify the runner’s current base when selecting him.
For the Buttons scheme, destination directions follow the diamond: right for first, up for second, left for third, and down for home. Check the in-game control diagram if you use remapped controls.
To send a runner from second to third:
On a hit to the outfield, decide where each runner should finish. Give the batter a conservative destination while assessing whether the lead runner can score.

Watch the outfielder’s pickup and throwing position. If the ball is fielded cleanly before the runner approaches third, avoid sending him simply because the hit looked deep. If you commit to home, target the lead runner individually.
Review a failed attempt by pausing at the moment you issued the command. Was the fielder already holding the ball? Had the runner reached third? Did you select the intended player? Those observations distinguish a risky decision from an input mistake.

Before the pitch, establish a plan for each runner. A possible scoring chance for the runner on third does not automatically justify advancing everyone.
For a potential tag-up, keep the trailing runner’s destination explicit while handling the lead runner. Practice selecting the runner on third without moving the runner on first.
Avoid an aggressive send solely to force the defense to react. Test the situation offline and judge whether the scoring opportunity justifies risking an out.
Use individual selection when only one runner needs a different destination. A group return command can interfere with a runner who was already moving correctly.
If one runner goes too far, identify him before entering a correction. Resist rapidly alternating advance and return inputs; that makes it harder to track which instruction you have issued.
Practice with two runners aboard. Give them different destinations, then correct only one. Focus on accurate selection before trying to execute the sequence faster.
Use a replay to separate selection errors from poor baserunning decisions.
| What Happened | What to Review | Recommended Adjustment |
|---|---|---|
| The wrong runner advanced | Which player you selected | Slow down the selection step |
| Several runners moved unexpectedly | Whether you used a group command | Assign destinations individually |
| A runner returned unnecessarily | Which return instruction you issued | Correct only the affected runner |
| A runner was thrown out taking an extra base | Fielder position when you committed | Choose a more conservative destination |
| A correction arrived too late | When you recognized the catch or pickup | Make the decision from the fielding action |
A faster card will not fix an incorrect command. Review the selection and destination before deciding that runner speed caused the out.
Keep one control scheme selected. Rehearse a runner going from second to third, a first-and-third situation, and two runners receiving different destinations. If you need additional resources to upgrade your bench with a faster runner, buying cheap MLB 26 stubs is also a good option. Use these practice situations to identify which role needs an upgrade before choosing a player.
After each play, check the runner selected, the base assigned, and the ball’s location when you committed. Correct the input if selection was wrong; change the decision if the command was accurate but the destination was too ambitious.
The U4GM Team