September's Standout Infielders: MLB The Show 25 Tier List

I've spent countless hours grinding in Diamond Dynasty, and with the season updates rolling in, the meta for infielders has shifted a bit this month. Whether you're building a squad for ranked play or just dominating events, these players stand out based on their stats, quirks, and how they perform in clutch situations. To keep my team stacked, I grab stubs from U4GM – quick delivery and no hassle, which lets me snag those high-diamond cards without the endless farm.

S-Tier Infielders: The Game-Changers

These guys are must-haves if you're serious about winning. They combine power, speed, defense, and those juicy attributes that make them unstoppable.

First Base (1B)

• Bryce Harper (Philadelphia Phillies, 95 OVR): Absolute beast with the bat, crushes lefties and righties alike. His vision and power make him a lineup anchor.
• Freddie Freeman (Los Angeles Dodgers, 90 OVR): Consistent contact hitter who rarely strikes out. Great for those high-pressure at-bats.
• Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Toronto Blue Jays, 90 OVR): Power for days, and his clutch quirk shines in late innings.

Second Base (2B)

• Ketel Marte (Arizona Diamondbacks, 96 OVR): Switch-hitter with elite speed and fielding. He's been meta all year for a reason.
• Mookie Betts (Los Angeles Dodgers, 95 OVR): Versatility king – plays multiple positions, hits for average, and steals bases like it's nothing.
• Chase Utley (Legend, 99 OVR): If you can afford the legend card, his contact against righties and solid defense make him S-tier forever.

Third Base (3B)

• Jose Ramirez (Cleveland Guardians, 95 OVR): Switch-hitter with power and speed. His arm strength saves runs on defense.
• Manny Machado (San Diego Padres, 86 OVR): Underrated this month, but his power surge in updates makes him a homer machine.
• Carlos Correa (Legend, 99 OVR): Elite fielding and balanced hitting. Perfect for locking down the hot corner.

Shortstop (SS)

• Bobby Witt Jr. (Kansas City Royals, 96 OVR): Speed demon with pop. He's been climbing tiers with his steals and extra-base hits.
• Francisco Lindor (New York Mets, 95 OVR): Switch-hitter who excels in the field. Clutch performer in big games.
• Gunnar Henderson (Baltimore Orioles, 94 OVR): Young gun with massive power potential. His recent buffs make him essential.

A-Tier Infielders: Solid Picks for Any Squad

Not quite elite, but these players can carry your team if built around properly. They're affordable via stubs from spots like U4GM and offer great value.

First Base (1B)

• Oscar Charleston (Legend, 99 OVR): Vintage power and speed, but quirky against certain pitchers.
• Dick Allen (Legend, 99 OVR): Hits bombs, solid defense, but availability in packs can be tricky.
• Salvador Perez (Legend, 99 OVR): More known as a catcher, but his 1B secondary makes him versatile with high contact.

Second Base (2B)

No major standouts here beyond S-tier, but keep an eye on season updates for boosts.

Third Base (3B)

• Rafael Devers (Boston Red Sox, 86 OVR): Lefty power bat that's reliable against right-handers.
• Matt Chapman (San Francisco Giants, 86 OVR): Gold Glove defense with improving offense.
• Eugenio Suarez (Arizona Diamondbacks, 86 OVR): Homer threat, but swings and misses a lot.

Shortstop (SS)

• Elly De La Cruz (Cincinnati Reds, 93 OVR): Insane speed (99 steal rating), but contact can be inconsistent.
• Corey Seager (Texas Rangers, 92 OVR): Pure hitter with power, though speed lacks.
• Trea Turner (Philadelphia Phillies, 90 OVR): Base stealer extraordinaire, great for small ball.

B-Tier and Below: Budget Options or Niche Fits

If you're just starting out or need fillers, look at guys like Lance Berkman (1B, 99 OVR Legend) for power on a budget, or Willy Adames (SS, 99 OVR) for defense. They're solid but won't win games alone. Avoid F-tier traps unless you're experimenting.

This tier list is based on current meta as of early September – things change with patches, so check updates. Stocking up on stubs from U4GM has helped me test these out quickly. What's your go-to infielder this month?