The All-Star Collection is now live in MLB The Show 26, and players are already racing to unlock the biggest reward of the event: 99 OVR Yordan Alvarez.
With elite power, a dangerous left-handed swing, and incredible hitting ability against right-handed pitchers, Yordan Alvarez has quickly become one of the most exciting offensive cards in Diamond Dynasty. However, completing the 43-card All-Star Collection can feel overwhelming if you do not have a clear plan.
All-Star Collection Reward Path
Before starting the grind, players should understand what they unlock along the way.
| Cards Collected | Reward | Value |
| 15 All-Star Cards | 97 OVR Mason Miller | Elite bullpen arm with dominant velocity |
| 25 All-Star Cards | 98 OVR Cam Schlittler | Strong rotation upgrade |
| 35 All-Star Cards | 98 OVR Bobby Witt Jr. | Speed, defense, and athleticism |
| 43 All-Star Cards | 99 OVR Yordan Alvarez | Endgame-level offensive weapon |
The collection rewards are designed so that every milestone improves your team. Even before reaching Yordan Alvarez, Mason Miller and Bobby Witt Jr. can immediately strengthen competitive Diamond Dynasty lineups.
Fastest Free All-Star Collection Route
The biggest mistake players make is completing every objective separately. The fastest method is to combine missions together and make every game provide multiple rewards.
The ideal order is:
Moments → All-Star Mission Team → Conquest → Showdown → Market Cleanup
Complete All-Star Moments First
Estimated Time: Around 1 Hour
Start by finishing the American League and National League Moments.
These challenges are the easiest way to earn your first group of All-Star cards because they require no investment and can be completed quickly.
The cards earned from Moments should immediately become part of your All-Star lineup for the next step.
Do not rush past this section. These free cards are the foundation of the entire collection grind.
Build an All-Star Team and Grind Conquest
Estimated Time: 2-3 Hours
After unlocking your first cards, create a dedicated All-Star mission lineup.
Do not use your main Ranked team. Instead, fill your roster with:
All-Star cards from Moments
Players with PXP missions
Hitters needing home runs or extra-base hits
Pitchers needing strikeouts
While playing Conquest, you can complete multiple objectives at the same time:
Earn map rewards
Gain PXP progress
Complete player missions
Unlock additional All-Star cards
This is the most efficient part of the grind because every game pushes several goals forward.
Finish Remaining Progress With Showdown
Estimated Time: Around 45 Minutes
After Conquest, Showdown becomes the final push.
Complete the available All-Star Showdowns to collect additional program progress and finish any remaining reward paths.
Doing Showdown after Conquest is more efficient because you already have most of the required cards and progress completed.
Smart Market Strategy For Missing Cards
Once all free rewards are collected, use Stubs carefully.
The goal is not to buy the strongest cards. The goal is simply reaching 43 collected cards.
Use the Community Market filters:
Series → All-Star
Then sort by the lowest Buy Now price.
Prioritize:
95-97 OVR All-Star cards
Low-demand players
Cards close to quick sell value
Avoid buying expensive 99 OVR cards immediately after release. Early prices are usually inflated because players are rushing to complete collections.
Save your MLB The Show 26 Stubs and only purchase the cheapest cards needed to finish the collection.
99 Yordan Alvarez Gameplay Review
After completing the collection, Yordan Alvarez becomes one of the best offensive upgrades available.
His biggest strength is his ability against right-handed pitching. His power, contact, and smooth swing make him extremely dangerous in Ranked play.
However, his defense is not elite. His speed and range are average for an outfielder, so competitive players should consider using a defensive replacement late in close games.
The fastest MLB The Show 26 All-Star Collection route is simple:
Complete Moments → Build an All-Star mission team → Grind Conquest → Finish Showdown → Buy cheap missing cards
With smart planning, players can unlock 99 Yordan Alvarez without wasting Stubs or unnecessary hours.
The All-Star Collection is one of the biggest roster upgrade opportunities of the season, and starting early gives you the best chance to dominate Diamond Dynasty with one of the most feared hitters in MLB The Show 26.
The U4GM Team