MLB The Show 26 All-Time Teams: How to Get 99 Greg Maddux and Other Legends

MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty is bringing back the All-Time Teams concept on November 13, giving players a new opportunity to compete against some of the strongest franchise-themed lineups in the game. The upcoming program features Awards Greg Maddux and five additional legendary player rewards.

There is also a separate All-Time Teams Extreme Program for players looking for a bigger challenge. It offers another version of 99 OVR Greg Maddux, making the November 13 content drop particularly interesting for players who want to strengthen their pitching rotation and expand their Legends collection.

What Is the All-Time Teams Program in MLB The Show 26?

The All-Time Teams Program is a new Diamond Dynasty content drop built around the best players associated with MLB franchises.

Players will compete against each franchise's best Diamond Dynasty players rather than simply facing ordinary opponents. These matchups provide a different challenge from standard Diamond Dynasty gameplay and give players a chance to earn legendary player cards.

According to the official announcement, the standard program includes six legendary player rewards:

• Awards Greg Maddux
• Five additional legends

The program launches on November 13, 2026. The complete list of legendary players and the individual mission requirements have not yet been fully revealed.

One important detail is that the announcement confirms five additional legends alongside Maddux. It does not confirm a separate reward card for every MLB franchise.

For players who enjoy collecting historical players or building themed Diamond Dynasty squads, this program is worth watching.

How to Unlock 99 OVR Awards Greg Maddux

Greg Maddux is the headline reward of the standard All-Time Teams Program.

The new 99 OVR Awards card represents his outstanding 1994 season with the Atlanta Braves. Maddux finished that season with a 16-6 record and a remarkable 1.56 ERA, winning his third consecutive National League Cy Young Award.

His reputation was built on exceptional control, pitch location, and the ability to consistently keep hitters off balance.

To unlock this version of Maddux, players should participate in the standard All-Time Teams Program when it becomes available on November 13.

The confirmed content includes franchise-based Diamond Dynasty matchups and six legendary player rewards. However, the exact mission structure, progression requirements, and reward checkpoints have not yet been announced.

Once the program goes live, check its in-game objectives and reward path to identify the most efficient way to earn Maddux.

For players who want to add a high-rated starting pitcher without taking on the more demanding Extreme content, the standard program should be the first priority.

All-Time Teams Extreme: How to Get the Other Greg Maddux Card

The standard All-Time Teams Program is not the only way to pursue a new 99 OVR Greg Maddux.

San Diego Studio has also confirmed a separate All-Time Teams Extreme Program. This additional challenge offers a variant version of the Awards Greg Maddux card.

Both versions feature Maddux as an Atlanta Braves starting pitcher and reference his historic 1994 season. However, they are separate card variants tied to different programs.

The standard All-Time Teams Program provides the regular Awards version, while All-Time Teams Extreme features the alternative version.

This distinction matters when planning your Diamond Dynasty progression. Players who simply want the new Maddux card can focus on the standard program first. Those who want the additional variant will need to take on the Extreme content as well.

The full Extreme mission requirements and difficulty details have not yet been confirmed, so it is best to wait for the in-game objectives before planning a specific completion route.

Why Greg Maddux Could Be a Valuable Addition to Your Rotation

Greg Maddux is an interesting pitcher for Diamond Dynasty players because his real-life success came from precision rather than overpowering velocity.

His 1994 season remains one of the strongest pitching performances of his career. A 1.56 ERA across 25 starts helped establish him as one of the most dominant pitchers of his generation.

For MLB The Show 26 players, the new 99 OVR Awards card could become an attractive rotation option.

However, overall rating alone does not determine whether a starting pitcher is effective. Pitch mix, individual attributes, control, velocity, and break all influence how a card performs in competitive games.

Players should compare Maddux's final attributes with their existing rotation before deciding whether he deserves a permanent starting spot.

It is also worth remembering that Diamond Dynasty performance depends on how comfortably a player can locate pitches and mix different offerings. A pitcher with excellent control can be particularly appealing to players who prefer carefully setting up hitters instead of relying on fastballs.

How to Prepare for the All-Time Teams Program

Although the exact missions have not been revealed, players can prepare for the November 13 update without spending unnecessary resources.

Build a Balanced Lineup

The program will feature franchise-themed Diamond Dynasty opponents. Having reliable hitters throughout your batting order can help you handle different pitching matchups and avoid depending on only one or two offensive players.

Review Your Starting Rotation

Maddux is the main attraction of the new content. Before the program launches, review your current starting pitchers and identify which rotation spots could use an upgrade.

Keep Your Bullpen Ready

A strong starting rotation is only part of a competitive Diamond Dynasty squad. Reliable relief pitchers can help protect leads and handle difficult late-game situations.

Manage Your MLB The Show 26 Stubs

Avoid spending all your MLB The Show 26 Stubs on unnecessary player cards before the new content arrives. Keeping some currency available gives you more flexibility when new cards and market opportunities appear.

There is no confirmed requirement to purchase additional players to unlock the standard Maddux reward. Wait for the official mission details before buying cards specifically for this program.

Standard All-Time Teams vs. All-Time Teams Extreme: Which Should You Play First?

Both programs offer a different reason to participate, but they may appeal to different types of Diamond Dynasty players.

For most players, the standard program is the logical starting point. It offers the main Awards Maddux card alongside five additional legendary rewards.

The Extreme version is an additional objective for players who want another Maddux variant and are prepared to take on more challenging content.

You do not need to commit to both programs immediately. Start with the standard rewards and decide whether the additional Extreme challenge is worthwhile after reviewing its requirements.

Final Thoughts

The MLB The Show 26 All-Time Teams Program arrives on November 13, bringing franchise-themed Diamond Dynasty matchups and six legendary player rewards, including 99 OVR Awards Greg Maddux.

The separate All-Time Teams Extreme Program adds another 99 OVR Maddux variant for players who want a greater challenge.

For most Diamond Dynasty players, the standard program should be the first target. It provides access to the main Maddux reward and five additional legends, while the Extreme version offers another collection goal.

Prepare your lineup, review your pitching rotation, and keep some Stubs available before the update goes live. Once the full missions and card attributes are revealed, players will have a clearer idea of how much time to invest in each program.

The U4GM Team